Stories of Open
Gathering and sharing lived experiences of open and peer review in Library and Information Science.
- It has to be about the material and whether it’s furthering the conversationThis is the second in a series of three presenting Debbie’s story. In the first part, Debbie shared her experiences submittingContinue reading “It has to be about the material and whether it’s furthering the conversation”
- Clear about process. I think that’s the most important thing.This is the first in a series of Debbie Schachter’s story. At the time of this interview, in August 2020, DebbieContinue reading “Clear about process. I think that’s the most important thing.”
- Identities in Peer Review: #peerreviewweek21It’s been quiet around here for summer while I took two months off to drive around the country to visit friendsContinue reading “Identities in Peer Review: #peerreviewweek21”
Everyone has a story to share. Whether you are a Library and Information Science (LIS) student, an experienced librarian, a journal editor, someone who referees, an author, or even someone who reads peer-reviewed LIS literature, you have experiences to share.
What was it like to have your work undergo peer review for the first time? How did peer review improve your work? How did you learn to serve as a referee? How do you approach requests to referee works? What is your refereeing philosophy? Have you participated in open peer review? What was it like? What other experiences have you had with peer review?
No story is too big or too small. No experience is insignificant. Your participation consists of an interview conducted via Skype, and a brief review of your story before it is published.
When we share our lived experiences with others, we can help create dialogue and we can begin to reflect as a community about this important publishing process.
This project builds upon the work of a forthcoming book from ACRL Press, whose working title is Stories of Open: Opening peer review through narrative inquiry, as well as an article appearing in College & Research Libraries, Tell Me Your Story: Narrative inquiry in LIS research.
Sharing stories allows others learn and reflect on their own experiences. Ultimately we can change the peer review system for the better.
Learn from the experiences folks have already shared.
Share your story
Share your own story of open or story about your peer review experiences.